Ultimate Tattoo Supply: A Lifecycle Program Rebuilt From the Deliverability Layer Up

A success story from a professional tattoo and body art supply brand whose email and SMS programs were inherited mid flight. Deliverability was compromised, Klaviyo and Attentive were run as strangers, and the flow library was thin. Campaign email opens now sit at 52.73 percent, flow opens at 59.78 percent, and a blended conversion rate of 5.09 percent.

Ultimate Tattoo Supply lifecycle turnaround success story hero, Atelier Commerce, Klaviyo, Attentive

Client

Ultimate Tattoo Supply

Duration

Ongoing

Date

Ultimate Tattoo Supply: A Lifecycle Program Rebuilt From the Deliverability Layer Up

A success story from a professional tattoo and body art supply brand whose email and SMS programs were inherited mid flight. Deliverability was compromised, Klaviyo and Attentive were run as strangers, and the flow library was thin. Campaign email opens now sit at 52.73 percent, flow opens at 59.78 percent, and a blended conversion rate of 5.09 percent.

Ultimate Tattoo Supply lifecycle turnaround success story hero, Atelier Commerce, Klaviyo, Attentive

Client

Ultimate Tattoo Supply

Duration

Ongoing

Date

We were brought in to take over the email and SMS program for a high volume tattoo and body art supply brand inside the Body Art Alliance group. The brand had the catalog, the audience, and a large SMS list already producing real revenue. What it did not have was a lifecycle program that worked as one system. Deliverability was compromised, email and SMS were run as strangers to each other, the automated flows that should carry a program were thin or missing, and the list had never been cleaned or properly segmented.

Michael J. McBride, Founder and CEO of Atelier Commerce, on the Ultimate Tattoo Supply lifecycle turnaround

Michael J. McBride

Founder and CEO, Atelier Commerce

BUILT WITH

We were brought in to take over the email and SMS program for a high volume tattoo and body art supply brand inside the Body Art Alliance group. The brand had the catalog, the audience, and a large SMS list already producing real revenue. What it did not have was a lifecycle program that worked as one system. Deliverability was compromised, email and SMS were run as strangers to each other, the automated flows that should carry a program were thin or missing, and the list had never been cleaned or properly segmented.

Michael J. McBride, Founder and CEO of Atelier Commerce, on the Ultimate Tattoo Supply lifecycle turnaround

Michael J. McBride

Founder and CEO, Atelier Commerce

BUILT WITH

A working tattoo studio at nine in the morning, needles in cassette trays, ink bottles capped, a purchase order open on a laptop between clients. The buyer inside that studio is professional, informed, and quick to unsubscribe from anything that reads like a robot. The program had been sending to a list that had never been cleaned, and the inbox had stopped opening.

A working tattoo studio at nine in the morning, needles in cassette trays, ink bottles capped, a purchase order open on a laptop between clients. The buyer inside that studio is professional, informed, and quick to unsubscribe from anything that reads like a robot. The program had been sending to a list that had never been cleaned, and the inbox had stopped opening.

Ultimate Tattoo Supply lifecycle scorecard: 52.73% campaign email open, 59.78% flow open, 5.09% blended conversion

Four broken systems, one B2B program built on demand it could not carry

Ultimate Tattoo Supply, part of the Body Art Alliance group, arrived at the engagement with the audience and the catalog already in place. A large SMS list was already producing real revenue. What was missing was a lifecycle program that worked as one system. Deliverability had been eroded by sending to an unmanaged list, and the inbox had stopped trusting the sender. Email lived in Klaviyo, SMS lived in Attentive, and the two were run as separate programs by separate logic, often colliding on the same buyer on the same day. The automated flows that carry a program were thin or missing. And the list itself had no segmentation or hygiene. Any one of those will cap a program. All four together had put a ceiling on a B2B brand already generating seven figure annual scale.

The picture we drew was unglamorous and non negotiable. Repair the sending domain first, because a lifecycle program is worth nothing if the messages never reach the inbox. Unify Klaviyo and Attentive under one coordinated calendar so email and SMS reinforce rather than fight. Build out the flow library from welcome through browse and cart recovery through post purchase, so automation carries the work that campaigns should not. Rebuild the list around engagement and segment by behavior and purchase history, then keep it clean on an ongoing cadence so the deliverability gains hold. Foundation, then reach, then compounding.

Four broken systems, one B2B program built on demand it could not carry

Ultimate Tattoo Supply, part of the Body Art Alliance group, arrived at the engagement with the audience and the catalog already in place. A large SMS list was already producing real revenue. What was missing was a lifecycle program that worked as one system. Deliverability had been eroded by sending to an unmanaged list, and the inbox had stopped trusting the sender. Email lived in Klaviyo, SMS lived in Attentive, and the two were run as separate programs by separate logic, often colliding on the same buyer on the same day. The automated flows that carry a program were thin or missing. And the list itself had no segmentation or hygiene. Any one of those will cap a program. All four together had put a ceiling on a B2B brand already generating seven figure annual scale.

The picture we drew was unglamorous and non negotiable. Repair the sending domain first, because a lifecycle program is worth nothing if the messages never reach the inbox. Unify Klaviyo and Attentive under one coordinated calendar so email and SMS reinforce rather than fight. Build out the flow library from welcome through browse and cart recovery through post purchase, so automation carries the work that campaigns should not. Rebuild the list around engagement and segment by behavior and purchase history, then keep it clean on an ongoing cadence so the deliverability gains hold. Foundation, then reach, then compounding.

Ultimate Tattoo Supply unified Klaviyo email and Attentive SMS on one coordinated calendar
Ultimate Tattoo Supply Welcome Series email in Klaviyo, largest share of flow revenue on its own
Ultimate Tattoo Supply unified Klaviyo email and Attentive SMS on one coordinated calendar
Ultimate Tattoo Supply Welcome Series email in Klaviyo, largest share of flow revenue on its own

What we inherited, and what we rebuilt

A lifecycle program is not a series of sends. It is a system with four load bearing parts, and all four were broken when we took over.

Deliverability was repaired and protected with engagement based sending, disciplined volume, and a re established sender reputation, so the inbox opened again. Email and SMS were unified into one coordinated calendar across Klaviyo and Attentive, with messaging cadence and suppression rules that treat the customer as one person across both channels. The flow library was built out, welcome, abandoned cart, browse recovery, and post purchase, and a single Welcome Series email drove the largest share of flow revenue on its own. Segmentation was rebuilt around engagement, behavior, and purchase history, and ongoing list hygiene was put in place to protect the gains. The result reads in the numbers the way the source doc did: 52.73 percent campaign email open rates, 59.78 percent flow open rates, and a 5.09 percent blended conversion rate, all above category norms. Email lifecycle revenue now compounds on top of an SMS program that already contributes the majority of the channel's revenue.

What we inherited, and what we rebuilt

A lifecycle program is not a series of sends. It is a system with four load bearing parts, and all four were broken when we took over.

Deliverability was repaired and protected with engagement based sending, disciplined volume, and a re established sender reputation, so the inbox opened again. Email and SMS were unified into one coordinated calendar across Klaviyo and Attentive, with messaging cadence and suppression rules that treat the customer as one person across both channels. The flow library was built out, welcome, abandoned cart, browse recovery, and post purchase, and a single Welcome Series email drove the largest share of flow revenue on its own. Segmentation was rebuilt around engagement, behavior, and purchase history, and ongoing list hygiene was put in place to protect the gains. The result reads in the numbers the way the source doc did: 52.73 percent campaign email open rates, 59.78 percent flow open rates, and a 5.09 percent blended conversion rate, all above category norms. Email lifecycle revenue now compounds on top of an SMS program that already contributes the majority of the channel's revenue.

Let’s bring your vision to life

Our approach brings marketing, experience, and retention into alignment so each stage of the journey performs with greater precision. Reach out and begin your journey with us.

Extreme close-up black and white photograph of a human eye

Contact us

Let’s bring your vision to life

Our approach brings marketing, experience, and retention into alignment so each stage of the journey performs with greater precision. Reach out and begin your journey with us.

Extreme close-up black and white photograph of a human eye

Contact us

Let’s bring your vision to life

Our approach brings marketing, experience, and retention into alignment so each stage of the journey performs with greater precision. Reach out and begin your journey with us.

Extreme close-up black and white photograph of a human eye

Contact us